A field of four candidates was whittled down to two during the primaries, leaving incumbent Cindy Gustafson going head-to-head with former planning commissioner Wayne Nader for the Placer County District 5 representative seat. Each candidate’s lengthy dais experience is reflected in their answers to questions about the county’s vexing issues for its eastern constituents. Answers edited for style and clarity. Order of responses determined by a randomizer.
What prevents projects from getting on the ground in Eastern Placer County?
Wayne Nader: The cost of construction and land values are extremely high versus other areas in Placer County. This makes the viability of projects in the Tahoe region very challenging. Multiple agencies review process and guidelines that justifiably are designed to protect the lake in the Basin, may also cause hesitation by developers. Infrastructure limitations, particularly the roadways, make growth inducing projects hard to fit into an already over-capacity issue. As stated in the previous question, I would be supportive of some appropriate incentives to encourage projects to move forward, especially redevelopment.
Cindy Gustafson: Fortunately, many public projects have gotten on the ground including sidewalks, trails, park improvements, and water and sewer infrastructure. Unfortunately, in our system of capitalism, private projects don’t come forward in an economy and under conditions that don’t allow a reasonable return on investment. Unless there is a property owner who can take the significant risk with their own funding, projects don’t happen. With interest rates high and the cost of construction doubling since 2014, it’s very difficult to make private projects pencil without large subsidies or other enticements to encourage those investments. Understandably, subsidies are extremely difficult for both decision-makers and the public. In addition, our regulatory and environmental requirements are excellent at protecting our environment, but they create an additional cost burden that requires further investment not required in other competing areas. A final component that generates risk for investors is that often a project will be challenged by individuals or groups all the way through the public process. In this atmosphere, small projects with minimal impacts struggle to break even, and there are few lenders interested in break-even investments. All of this creates very difficult conditions for projects to be successful and “get on the ground.”
The role of District 5 Supervisor is a balancing act. How do you plan to walk the line of respecting North Tahoe’s social and environmental capital while also promoting economic growth?
Cindy Gustafson: This is at the very root of so many of our challenges in the North Lake Tahoe region. Considered the “pillars of sustainability” it is absolutely critical that policy decisions balance all three — social, environmental, and economic interests. This is something I work on each and every day. I believe it requires a deep understanding of the local issues, identifying the interested groups, and a dedication to bringing the community together to ensure that all interests are represented in the decision-making process. Throughout my career in the region, I have been successful in bringing disparate groups and individuals together to facilitate common understanding and decision-making to improve our communities. It is not a supervisor’s job to dictate what happens, but to facilitate the best outcomes for the community as a whole. Walking that line is not a job I have ever done, nor could possibly do on my own. It requires committed problem solvers and dedicated community champions to make progress happen on all three pillars. My job as a supervisor is to bring all those interests together to a place where compromises and solutions can be found.
Wayne Nader: I served on the Placer County Planning Commission from 2012 to 2020. During that time some notable Tahoe projects came before the commission. On each project I spent a significant amount of time reviewing it with the planning staff, reading in detail the submittal information, meeting with the applicant, and those in opposition to it. I was then fully prepared for the hearing on each project, so that I could render a decision that best reflected whether or not it would be in the best interest of the community and the broad implications that came with it.
I have stated that I am a proponent of redevelopment over new development. Kings Beach and Tahoe City clearly need a refresh in their central core. I would use incentives to encourage the upgrading of these properties. I would support implementing a priority review and approval process, fee reductions, and tax incentives to make projects more feasible for the property owners.
The quality of life for the residents and the experience for visitors are being jeopardized by growth that cannot be sustained due to capacity limitations, especially the limited roadway structure. That is why I feel the best path forward is through redevelopment.
Is the county adequately addressing workforce housing needs? Why or why not?
Wayne Nader: Workforce housing is an issue throughout Placer County, but it is most acute in the Tahoe area. Business and municipal organizations are struggling to find employees. Some businesses, especially restaurants, have had to cut back on hours of operations and services due to the shortage of available staffing. During my time as a planning commissioner, I was disappointed that Placer County was not holding developers accountable to providing workforce housing within their projects. Too often they were given the option to pay an in-lieu fee rather than build these units. The fee was substantially less than what it would be to actually construct this type of housing, so of course the developers pursued that option. Now the county is trying to play catchup when costs to build these units has more than doubled. This is making it difficult to impossible to get this desperately needed housing constructed. I would require that all projects incorporate a substantial number of actual units toward workforce housing.
Cindy Gustafson: Throughout California workforce housing is a significant challenge, but in resort areas it is truly a crisis. I don’t believe the county is doing enough, but we are doing far more in Eastern Placer than anywhere else in the county. Construction costs have skyrocketed, interest rates are high, and these are combined with a very limited supply of developable land. Housing prices continue to escalate far exceeding local incomes and rental rates alone can’t offset costs for construction. We need dedicated funding to provide opportunities. I strongly supported both the ballot measure for the permanent increase in transient occupancy tax, and the partnership with the business community to establish the TBID, each of which have helped secure funds for Lease to Locals and the Workforce Housing Preservation Program, which unlock existing housing. A new program called Launchpad is being designed to spur investment in small housing projects through low interest loans and deed restrictions. As new private projects come forward, they are required to provide more housing than similar projects in west Placer County. We still need to do more. Building back local workforce is essential for our community’s future. We need to invest much more to make that happen.





