The Tahoe Truckee Unified School District will look a bit different next fall. Several ‘reconfiguration’ decisions were made April 22 during a meeting which saw the District’s Board of Trustees and administrators pelted with two hours of public comment ranging from stern finger-wagging – ‘We need to give this some time’ – to barbed pitchforks – ‘I don’t trust you guys, sorry.’
The Board – internally at odds – sat front and center in the North Tahoe High School gymnasium. A climbing wall towered behind them, a blue partition exclaiming ‘No Climbing’ separating the trustees from the wall’s multi-colored knobs. By meeting’s end, the Board opted – via a 3-2 vote – to go with a plan dubbed Configuration B.
The district reconfiguration talk was a change – kind of – from a season otherwise mired in efforts to salvage the District from a $4 million budget shortfall. While the official TTUSD stance is that the changes are not necessarily designed to save money, Superintendent Steve Jennings said the reconfiguration calls had to be made prior to moving ahead with the budget.
At district offices the following week, Jennings said he didn’t feel comfortable making further budget decisions without the roadmap that reconfiguration provided: ‘This is certainly part of the puzzle,’ he said. ‘To me, this is kind of the lynchpin decision.’
Configuration B focuses on changes for lakeside schools. Both elementary schools will become kindergarten through third grade, with Tahoe Lake Elementary offering an English Mainstream program and Kings Beach Elementary concentrating on Two-Way Immersion. North Tahoe Middle School will absorb lakeside fourth and fifth graders, while allowing students in the seventh and eighth grades to partake of certain courses – such as such as math and foreign language classes, as well as electives – at North Tahoe High School. The plan also calls for schedules at both North Tahoe and Truckee High School to be synced up so that students may take advantage of courses at each campus.
In an effort to raise the District’s educational standards, officials have kicked around various reconfiguration concepts for years. The current economic woes, however, have apparently breathed new urgency into the matter.
‘Is this a budget meeting or a reconfiguration meeting?’ posed TTUSD Assistant Superintendent, Financial Services Steve Dickinson, after some amount of confusion was murmured from the public gallery. ‘It’s really both.’
Dickinson – the chief bean counter throughout this budget process – said that although the reconfiguration was not designed primarily to save money, the District would be tracking the financial results. Under Configuration B, the estimated savings due to the elementary school shake-ups will be between $3,000 and $30,000, while the middle and high school changes are expected to net between $15,000 and $45,000 in reduced costs.
Configuration B – along with, naturally, Configuration A – was proposed during a budget workshop the previous night as the final candidates for the reconfiguration plan. The two scenarios were culled from a longer list of options compiled by committees consisting of TTUSD officials and administrators.
No one seemed terribly excited by either of the final choices. Board member Bill Kraus, with an almost anti-climactic shrug, eventually made the motion to go with Configuration B.
‘Inaction, in and of itself, is action,’ he told his fellow trustees before calling for a vote.
Apparently, the best plan the District came up with – financially and educationally – was to combine both the middle and high schools. The estimated savings of such a move would have been between $250,000 and $350,000.
‘That wasn’t going to happen,’ Jennings said, leaning back in his office chair. ‘That was pretty clear. The community made that clear.’
Throughout a series of community meetings held in recent months, there has been a common theme: don’t close our schools.
District officials decided to scrap the notion of closures and combinations, and moved on to other options.
‘We choose to honor the feedback that we heard and we left schools open in every community,’ Trustee Bev Ducey said, in defense of the two scenarios presented at the meeting.
If the Board of Trustees seemed less than excited about the decision before them, the public in attendance was downright bummed. While there was the scant let’s-just-make-a-call-already sentiment, the bulk of the voices taking to the microphone didn’t have anything nice to say about the prospects of scenario A or B.
‘We’re all very upset and emotional because you’re messing with our children,’ said Sue Briggs.
With one child currently in the seventh grade at North Tahoe Middle School, and one heading into the sixth next year, Briggs’ family will be feeling the effects of the board’s final decision.
‘Children are not resources to be moved from one place to the other,’ she said.
Both scenarios included cuts in full-time employees. Bill Hudson, of Truckee, urged the board to work to loosen the confines of current contracts so that teachers with less seniority aren’t automatically the first to lose their jobs. Hudson said such an environment would create a ‘Donner Party Part II Effect.’
‘Kill all the young teachers, eat’em, then rationalize it as though it were the only option,’ he explained.
Many of the speakers expressed concern over the fact that the proposals were still warm on the table. They urged the board to take some time – as much as a year – before making any reconfiguration decisions.
‘I can’t believe you are considering a vote tonight – you’ve only had this in front of you for 24 hours,’ said Jeff Rose, the father of a junior at North Tahoe. ‘Months of generating fear, 140 pink slips, threats of school closures and the best you can come up with is basically a proposal from several years back, with a few tweaks, and only impacts for the North Shore – it feels as if you’re treating us as if we’re stupid.’
Two of the Trustees themselves were also against the idea of voting on a reconfiguration plan. Both Lisa Mohun and Kirsten Livak – the two newly elected members of the board who voted nay on the configuration vote – expressed their opposition with the move.
‘The reconfiguration at this time is just too much stress on our families,’ Mohun told her colleagues. ‘I think there’s just too many unanswered questions, so I’m voting no.’
Once passed, Jennings painted the measure as the beginning of the journey toward budgetary reconciliation. A few days later it would be a puzzle piece and lynchpin, but for now the reconfiguration was one of many ‘magic pills.’
‘It seems like in society in general we’re always looking for the magic pill – that there’s one thing that’s going to cure everything that we need to have cured,’ Jennings said. ‘There are a lot of magic pills out there and we need to be taking advantage of all of them and they’re all intertwined.’
A couple of the other magic pills – insofar as the budget goes – are reducing staff and streamlining the District’s overall operations. The first began with the Friday-the-13th pink-slip bonanza in March, and still continues with incremental reductions in the number of laid-off employees.
The week following the reconfiguration decision, the District and the Tahoe Truckee Education Association reached an agreement to further reduce the number of people to lose their job, bringing the number of full-time positions to be cut from 42 to 34. Originally, about 100 District employees were facing the cold.
This latest agreement sees the equivalent of eight full-time positions saved. It also included more attractive retirement incentives for teachers in the hopes that retiring, higher-paid, teachers might leave and allow their fresher, lower-paid, counterparts to be rehired. Also as part of the deal, the TTEA agreed to call off any possible legal action in response to the recent layoffs.
The two parties announced the agreement jointly. The TTUSD and TTEA have agreed not to speak to the media on the matter independently of each other.
In the vein of streamlining, the District lopped another $479,000 off its budget May 7 in non-classroom reductions. The cuts were made in the arenas of transportation, custodial and secretarial. The Board is aiming to thin about $180,000 more from the non-classroom column.
‘It’ll be difficult,’ Dickinson said. ‘But, yeah, we’ll get there.’
On May 14 the Board got around $47,000 closer by voting to charge parents for transporting their children on buses to and fro school. Unless a child qualifies for free or reduced lunch, they’ll need to pony up $150 annually to ride the cheese.
Outside of non-classroom, Dickinson is looking to make an additional $800,000 in cuts. This month the District will be taking a look at certain classified employee positions (instructional and library aides) and Jennings will attempt to tackle the administrative aspects of the budget. Dickinson expects the Superintendent’s proposal for administrative cuts sometime soon.
‘I’m not sure,’ Dickinson said. ‘I’m not sure what the proposal will be.’
While District officials struggle to cut the weight necessary to balance the budget, it now appears the task will not be as difficult as originally thought. As Dickinson explained to the crowd in the gymnasium during the reconfiguration meeting, the TTUSD may be in store for some of the federal stimulus money – as much as $860,000 – currently flowing from D.C.
‘There’s still a question mark, but there appears to be a pretty large amount of money – one-time money – that’s going to come to us,’ he said. ‘It appears that our reasonable worst-case scenario is getting better.’
With the target still set at $4 million, District players hope to have a preliminary budget ready by the end of May. But then, the math, alas, hinges on various May 19 ballot initiatives and the state’s budget, which isn’t due until June. Look for the results on your county’s election website.
On election-day eve, Jennings didn’t seem to have the pep normally brimming from behind his glasses. Instead, there was something akin to sad resolve: if he took the May 19 ballot to the track, he knew all his horses would lose.
‘I would certainly like to see everything pass,’ Jennings said, ‘but I’d be surprised if more than one passes.’





