(Editor’s Note, Nov. 17, 2008): Just two days after press, Ann Westling sent a release announcing an extension of the deadline for public comments. Public comments need to be postmarked by December 26, 2008. Comments can be sent to the: Tahoe National Forest, Travel Management Team, 631 Coyote St, Nevada City, CA 95959 or via email: tnf_rte_desig@fs.fed.us.)
David Lass sees the Little Truckee River as a refuge, not only for the anglers that cast their lines into the clear water, but also for the fish and the riparian shores. Lass calls fly-fishing the ‘quiet sport.’
Amy Granat sees the backcountry as a balm for her spirit. Wearing braces on both legs, ‘relying on my four-wheel drive jeep is the only way that I can get in the wilderness to go camping, hunting or fishing.’ Granat is a ‘tread trainer,’ advocating and teaching others how to tread lightly.
John Timmer has spent most of his life in the backcountry, and can empathize with forest rangers, after being one himself in Yosemite. Grouse Ridge is one of his favorite hiking areas; to get to the trailhead, he uses a maintained ‘street-legal’ forest service road. At least for now.
Three individuals, representing three interest groups that want the U.S. Forest Service to hear their voice during the comment period for the Tahoe National Forest Travel Management Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) that ends on November 26. The Tahoe National Forest stretches from the top of Donner Summit westward to the foothills of the western Sierra. Measuring 13,000 square miles, the Tahoe National Forest motto is ‘caring for the land and serving people.’ The DEIS has made some people wonder whom the forest service is serving.
Off-highway vehicle use has substantially increased over the past 30 years, especially in California. According to a briefing paper from the Tahoe National Forest (TNF), ‘The purpose of this travel management process is to protect forest resources while providing a challenging and diverse motorized trail and road system that accesses the forest for a variety of recreational opportunities.’
Those recreational opportunities include fishing, hiking, camping, mountain biking, cross-country skiing, horseback riding, OHV (off-highway-vehicles), dirt bike riding, jeeping and other off-road motorized activities. And some backcountry enthusiasts combine OHV with other activities. Each group agrees with parts of the proposed EIS alternatives, and in ways as varied as their activities, disagree with other parts.
David Lass is the Northern California Field Coordinator for Trout Unlimited (TU). The mission of TU is conserving, protecting and restoring North American fish and their watershed.’ Lass’s office is in Truckee, where they just finished shooting a film about the Little Truckee River. Lass said that TU is leaning toward the ‘preferred alternative,’ (See Alternatives Sidebar) with a few amendments including keeping proposed routes out of Castle Peak and the West Yuba. ‘Trout Unlimited is not so worried about the number of roads, but we want to protect the last best places to hunt and fish (i.e. inventoried roadless and headwater areas) in California. Riparian areas and aquatic species such as trout are most vulnerable to the impacts of OHV use. Lass is also concerned about the asymmetric relationship between the flyfisher and a motorized off-road vehicle. ‘The Forest Service is federally mandated to manage against user conflict…let’s create a system where we’re protecting our resources, and also protect users’ experiences that may be in conflict with another.’
Amy Granat is the Northern California Director of California Off-Road Vehicle Association (CORVA). Her group is requesting a modified alternative, believing that none of the alternatives exactly meet the needs of the off-road community. According to the Forest Service, the ‘off-road community’ is anyone that takes a vehicle off a paved road. Granat says that includes an extensive group of enthusiasts, including dirt bike, all-terrain vehicles (ATV), jeeps, and others that want to get into the backcountry.
‘Restrictions will affect everyone who accesses the forests. It amazes me, anyone who wants a more intimate experience in the backcountry will be affected by this proposed action.’ CORA would like to see amendments regarding seasonal trail closures (she calls them ‘management by closure’), and sees the deadline for the completion of the EIS on March 2009 as an arbitrary deadline. According to an email from David Arrasmith, Forest Planner for the Tahoe National Forest, the deadline was established by the Regional Office of the Forest Service. ‘We have been working on this project since 2003. It applies to almost all National Forest in California. Continuing the planning effort reduces the amount of funds available for operation and maintenance of roads and trails.’
John Timmer is a longtime volunteer with the South Yuba River Citizens League based in Nevada City. He volunteers ‘to help the river that I love.’ Timmer believes that most of the people that access the backcountry may bring their interests into the forests, but still, they care for the land. Yet he’s seen the damage done. ‘I see toilet paper and human waste, right on the banks of the Yuba River. That is most disturbing, people don’t seem to use common sense along the river.’ Timmer was hiking along an OHV trail when he came upon an oil spill in a spring. ‘Someone had created a mosh pit, 20-feet wide in the spring.
They created this hole that was so big, that they broke their oil pan getting out.’ Timmer would like to see changes to the preferred alternative, including stopping the proposed classification change of roads going into Grouse Ridge on the west side, and ensuring that the current ‘unauthorized routes’ that impinge on the Castle Peaks roadless areas are closed and not brought into the OHV system. He would also like to see the the Pierce Creek area of the Yuba River closed to OHV. Timmer said teaching people the ways of the backcountry is integral to keeping the forest intact. ‘There are very many fine people, in all of these groups. Part of the solution is education and enforcement.’
Ann Westling, Public Affairs Officer for the TNF encourages everyone to read the DEIS, and to submit your comments.
‘Currently, people may be driving dirt roads to get to the backcountry. We want to make sure that people pay attention to the process…your favorite backcountry road may or may not be part of the established road system. The DEIS may affect that road system.’ The comment period ends November 26, with the final EIS decision announced next spring. The final product, a Motor Vehicle Use Map will be available in fall 2009.
For a good quick roundup on what this Tahoe National Forest DEIS addresses and what the different alternatives are, visit MoonshineInk.com.
DEIS available at: fs.fed.us/r5/tahoe/projects_plans/ohv_inv/DEIS_overview.shtml
Send comments to: tnf_rte_desig@fs.fed.us
For a good quick roundup on what this Tahoe National Forest DEIS addresses and what the different alternatives are, click here.




