Some friends I know have a nightly ritual that I love. At dinner with their kids they play “Roses and Thorns” to discuss the day. Each family member takes a turn talking about the best part of the day (the roses) and the worst part of the day (the thorns).
I began thinking about the past seven years of real estate in terms of roses and thorns. We all know the real estate market just finished a very thorny seven years when the market tanked. Perhaps you lost your home, your credit, your savings, or all three. Maybe it happened to a family member, a neighbor, or a friend.
Working in the real estate market from 2007 to 2010 was challenging, with roughly 40 percent of local sales being distressed, mortgage companies tightening their reins, and banks entering the real estate market as sellers. Nevertheless, as the Tahoe/Truckee real estate market gains some distance off the bottom, I find myself reflecting on the roses in the rubble, the bright spots in a dark real estate history. There are success stories that happened in our community despite the bleak fallout — folks who waited, saved, and were able to take advantage of low prices and interest rates, or people who saw for the first time since the late 1980s that it was more affordable to buy a home than rent. These savvy buyers exercised patience in navigating a short sale, or stayed the course as one of many offers on a foreclosure, or moved up into a home that would’ve previously been unaffordable a few years prior. In the end, they managed to buy in one of the worst markets in history, yet one of the best markets for buyers. And I’m not talking about investors or “flippers” from out of the area, but locals who are now full-time home owners.
THE SHORT SALE
Jeff Dostie and fiancée Sarah Kunnen are newer homeowners in the Prosser neighborhood of Truckee. They started home shopping when their Realtor told them of a great short sale under $300,000. While the process took six months and many hoops to jump through, Jeff and Sarah recalled the process as being “pretty stress free.” By staying the course and being in constant communication with their Realtor and lender, Dostie and Kunnen successfully navigated the short sale process, a path that can be frustrating for buyers due to the long wait for the bank’s response. Although their offer was higher than they initially planned, in the end they purchased a newer home for a very good price; their mortgage is now cheaper than their former rent. Hanging in there on a long escrow for a short sale allowed the couple to become homeowners for an affordable price.
“I remember in 1998 to 1999 when friends were buying homes. It didn’t seem possible for us,” Dostie said. “When Sarah got a full-time job, we realized that together we could do it. We wanted to be able to afford to buy a house but not compromise our life as we live it.”
Kunnen enjoys the freedom that ownership provides. “I love coming home and spending time there,” she said. “You can input your own style in your house.”
A PERFECT MATCH
While not a distressed sale, Jesse Bushey and Emily Turner’s new home had been in the previous owner’s family for many generations and moving them out was no small feat. Still, both Bushey and Turner felt they had found a home that expresses exactly who they are and how they wish to live in the community. Their rustic cabin, located along the Truckee River between Alpine Meadows and Tahoe City, gets clean water from an old redwood water tower that is serviced from a local spring. They have to walk outside to the outhouse to use the bathroom and shower. While giving off the feeling of being at a fun summer mountain camp, this property is certainly not for the lighthearted. Yet it is perfect for Bushey and Turner.
“I feel responsible for this area and connected to this place — the creek, the erosion, what we have around,” Bushey said.
Having grown up in small-town Vermont comes in handy for Bushey, who together with Turner enjoys the long list of improvements required to maintain their property.
“I think it’s the coolest,” Turner said. “I love to walk across the bridge and call this my home. Friends come over and I’m so psyched to have it and to share it. It feels like it’s the right place for us, and I’m confident in that.”
MOVING ON UP
James “Woody” and Amanda Woodruff are longtime local homeowners who saw last summer as the right time to move into a bigger home that suited their family’s growing need for more space. When I asked Woody how his family of four was able to move up in the down economy, his answer was simple: “Fiscal responsibility is the only reason that we were able to upgrade. In a time when a lot of people were overextending themselves, we just didn’t do that…The interest rates allowed us to move up into a bigger house that we can afford.”
The Woodruffs made the move up last summer, having gotten a good price for their smaller home in Truckee and a great price for their new home in the Pannonia Ranchos neighborhood, situated on five sunny acres. When asked about his family’s favorite part of their new home, Woody said, “Location and neighbors. Now we have Prosser Reservoir and acreage, horses in the neighborhood, and it’s really close to town.”
Though the thorns of the depressed real estate market scratched many, it’s nice to know that some came out smelling like roses.
~ Comment on this column below.





