True Grit
One of my literary heroes recently resurfaced when an unusual press release dropped into my email inbox talking about John Steinbeck, the Tahoe City Fish Hatchery, and something about ‘shooting holes in the ceiling with a revolver.’
I’m a sucker for news items that mix firearms and literature, so I continued reading. But a few seconds into the email, I came to a sentence that made me want to pull out a revolver and start shooting holes in my own ceiling.
After describing Steinbeck’s little-known history at Lake Tahoe, the release made this bold and dubious statement: ‘With Steinbeck’s once-tarnished literary reputation once again on the rise as a ‘green’ eco-aware author, his Tahoe years (including his informal biology lessons here at the Fish Hatchery) loom even larger in significance today.’
The words ‘once-tarnished’ and ‘eco-aware’ were still ringing in my brain when I started thinking about Steinbeck, our culture of adoration, and the devaluation of honesty.
My heroes have always been deeply flawed, uncertain artists who embrace their human frailties and build authentic, honest art as masters who refuse to disguise their weaknesses.
But today, whether in nonfiction or fiction, the world wants to pretend at perfection. We are all gluttons for the perfect story, the moral narrative with a heavenly glow sprinkled with just enough sanitized earthiness to make it feel authentic.
The most recent, sad example of our hunger for too-good-to-be-true tales is the damaging news that calls into question the truthfulness of Greg Mortenson’s bestselling narrative in ‘Three Cups of Tea.’ Whatever comes of that controversy, the book that became a Bible to so many readers now seems to have felt a little too good, and lacked a little imperfection.
‘
Conversely, imperfection was one of the chief knocks on Steinbeck’s expansive, ambitious, and honest writing. I always found that criticism both arrogant and hollow, as if the critics somehow didn’t have the heart or spirit to understand the deep beauty of that fallibility.
I love the grit and the grime in Steinbeck’s books, the powerful thoughts projected through ragged characters like Tom Joad, and the mystic, lyrical mixture of novel and thought. I love that, like life, Steinbeck’s books are not neat or clean.
I grew up in Salinas surrounded by Steinbeck. In an alluvial valley where millions of tons of river silt created a culture embedded in the earth, the Steinbeck house was steps down the street, and the places and faces of ‘East of Eden’ walked by each day. The valley’s damp, dark soil provided me with my first job — hoisting irrigation pipes across endless furrows of lettuce and cauliflower with teams of hard-working Mexican transplants — and gave me my first taste of the farmwork that was the foundation of Steinbeck’s most famous writing.
Steinbeck’s history in Tahoe remained a mystery to me until years ago when I began reading the exhaustively researched biography by Jackson Benson. Holed up in a Cascade Lake cabin through long winters, Steinbeck wrote his earliest novel, ‘Cup of Gold,’ chopped firewood, and eventually landed a job at the Tahoe City Fish Hatchery, a post from which he was unceremoniously fired.
Steinbeck’s early life was as inglorious and imperfect as his future critics would label his literary work. He hung out with salty game wardens and steamboat captains, and chased women with the ungainly shyness and social ineptitude that would define his character for years to come. And, apparently, he also found time to shoot holes in a ceiling or two with a revolver.
In later years these qualities would open up a deep divide between Steinbeck and the urban literary critics in New York, who launched relentless, condescending attacks on the author’s work from their high-rise Manhattan offices. As he was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature, he addressed these critics in a deep, guttural roar — a tenacious tone that underlined the distinction between his blue-collar bloodlines and his critics’ insular disassociation from the dirt and trees and sweat and blood.
‘Literature was not promulgated by a pale and emasculated critical priesthood singing their litanies in empty churches — nor is it a game for the cloistered elect, the tin-horn mendicants of low-calorie despair. Literature is as old as speech. It grew out of human need for it and it has not changed except to become more needed,’ he said.
Unlike the universal praise and worldwide celebrity that greeted Greg Mortenson as ‘Three Cups of Tea’ gained popularity, Steinbeck’s Nobel Prize selection drew heavy criticism. He left Salinas to live in New York, hated in his hometown and across much of the country following his publication of ‘Grapes of Wrath.’ He was ostracized by Monterey’s social elite, persecuted by politicians, and belittled by critics.
Over time, the powerful truths of Steinbeck’s work have not dimmed at all. The literary career of one the country’s most authentic authors, germinated on the shores of Lake Tahoe, is today as relevant as ever.
We can all use a few more human heroes like Steinbeck — honest in their imperfections but powerful in their truthful assessment of raw humanity. At a time like this, a little more Steinbeck, and a little less self-aggrandizing memoir, could do us all some good.
‘~ Comment on this column below.





