BY SUSAN LINDSTROM
Thank you for considering my comments on your recent article in the June issue of Moonshine Ink, “The Traces We Leave: Graffiti + Petroglyphs at Donner Summit” by Lis Korb.
I’m surprised at the lack of editorial filter on the part of Moonshine Ink in printing an article that condones and encourages graffiti vandalism on the historic railroad tunnels at Donner Summit. “I’ve heard of the painted tunnels for years,” reports author Lis Korb. “The best piece [of graffiti] I found takes up much of the right wall as you enter the second tunnel to the east. A bearded face of Dali-esque proportions and a naked woman’s body with a bird head and wings are joined by wildstyle, three-dimensional type.” She continues: “Street art and graffiti are often called out as aggression toward urban spaces, the artists lashing out with paint at the structures they feel alienated by. In this way, I think graffiti is very appropriate for this abandoned, man-made space marring the mountain … the graffiti … makes the monstrosity somewhat more bearable.”
This “monstrosity” happens to be State Historic Landmark No. 780, the first Transcontinental Railroad, a world-renowned marvel of 19th century engineering. Summit Tunnel (Tunnel No. 6), of which she speaks, was one of the 15 Sierra tunnels. Being 1,659 feet long, it was the longest and hardest to bore. Working from east and west faces and from a shaft sank above the center, construction took two years to complete. For 24 hours a day, every day, Chinese workers pounded and blasted granite rock, making progress that was measured only in inches a day. The railroad was completed in May 1869. Where it had taken four to five months to cross the continent in a wagon train, travelers could now cross in just 10 days. As a tribute to this achievement and in recognition of the dangerous work due to avalanche, frostbite, explosion, and rockslides, Stanford University has launched an international research project on Chinese railroad workers in order to better understand this little known chapter of American history.
This graffiti should be removed from the tunnels to discourage others from damaging this landmark. And, the nearby petroglyphs that columnist Lis Korb also references in her article (Native American rock etchings that may be thousands of years old) are also in jeopardy. As of last year, U.S. Forest Service personnel noticed the first paint graffiti vandalism since they’ve been monitoring the petroglyph site over the past several decades.
Moreover, and history and prehistory aside, the graffiti on the train tunnels, which can be easily seen from Old Highway 40, now distorts the world class natural landscape of Donner Pass enjoyed by many thousands of residents and visitors.
In answer to Ms. Korb’s question: “Is leaving a trace (graffiti) on a trace (concrete tunnel) all that bad?” Graffiti artists should know that there are legal consequences. Individuals who vandalize archaeological and historical sites and landmarks on private or state lands (such as graffiti on the train tunnels) can be subject to prosecution as a misdemeanor charge, and on federal lands the act of vandalism (such as graffiti now occurring at the petroglyphs) could be prosecuted as a felony.
~ Susan Lindström, Ph.D., is a consulting archaeologist who lives in Truckee.
Editors Note: The column referenced above (Lis Korb’s DiStill Life) was not a news article. Columns and news articles differ in that columns offer Moonshine Ink contributors a chance to voice opinions and perspectives on issues, while news articles represent objective reporting. Moonshine Ink welcomes opinions and perspectives from both regular columnists and members of the community.




