Fragile Forests, Fragile Economy

0

The Lake Tahoe Region depends on healthy forests. No one visits Tahoe to look at clear-cuts and stumps. When ecosystems suffer, so goes the economy. Strong, vigorous forest protection is not optional for Lake Tahoe. It is, in fact, everything.

I was stunned to see clear-cut logging along Blackwood Creek that also included the campground. The USFS Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit confirmed the logging at Blackwood took place in July 2024 and is part of a mechanical thinning project. The entire 355-acre project was issued a categorical exclusion under the National Environmental Policy Act. Completion was slated for mid-October 2024. The USFS confirmed it is not complete; no final completion date was given.

According to the LTBMU’s website, “In addition to temporary impacts to recreational access, other impacts from fuels reduction projects include changes to the appearance of Tahoe Basin forests. Treated areas may look disturbed at first but recover visually within a few years.”

Advertisement

It’s been a year. The area is not recovering visually, the logic of which makes no sense: if you want it to recover, why the level of devastation in the first place? Also, recovering visually is not the same thing as recovering ecologically.

Environmental regulations and land ethics follow a policy of avoid, minimize, and mitigate regarding impacts. It also has financial logic — avoiding impacts saves taxpayers’ money. It is at its core common sense. For example, using an existing road versus building a new one. However, logging in July, at the height of the growing/breeding season for birds, wildlife, and native flora, especially going into a drier period, is not avoidance/reduction of impacts. It is, in fact, the opposite. Logging in peak summer maximizes impacts. It goes against the very tenet of responsible environmental regulatory planning.

Blackwood Creek drains into Lake Tahoe. The USFS confirmed that no hydrological analysis was done, i.e., how the complete removal of the forest/overstory may affect the watershed. Opening forests changes the hydrology, which then changes forest composition.

Mass destruction of a forest is traumatic and destructive. It is the evisceration of the engine of life we call forest ecosystems — interconnected living engines above and below ground, native plants that provide canopy layers for all other forest life, that store carbon, build our soil, clean our air, provide our oxygen, store and filter our snow pack and water, provide flood control, prevent erosion, cool the land and asphalt, and feed our spirit. One-stop shopping. One tree provides all this, thousands support the planet. A gift.

Traditional forestry practices are now destructive under climate change. Research indicates the more pristine forests are at a tipping point — one catastrophic event and the damage could be permanent. A forest doesn’t know that it was cut for forest health or fire safety. All it knows is that it was gutted under already stressful climate change conditions.

What is it that makes us think we can just keep pounding these ecosystems and, as the USFS says, it will all “just come back?” It won’t. Direct hits to forests are direct hits to forests, and all species that depend on them. With every pounding, they lose their resilience. Every native plant-dominated ecosystem is now like glass that has been dropped a few times but still has not broken. Once the native plants disappear, the entire ecosystem collapses, resulting in ecological dead zones, just like in the ocean. Science and our own field work over two decades confirms this. The forest in Blackwood Canyon can’t come back as it was. The native plant understory, its genetic reservoir, is now buried in feet of tinder curing in the hot sun.

Predictably, the Trump administration has made it easier to mess with our public lands. This includes logging them with little to no environmental review or public input.

Our remaining nearly pristine forests are precious. We must protect what’s left ecologically, which also means economically.   

~ Virginia Moran has been a professional ecologist in California for over 40 years. She holds a bachelor’s in field biology and a master’s in botany. She lost her home in San Diego’s Cedar Fire in 2003 despite a fire clearing project. She has studied this issue ever since. Learn more about her environmental consulting company at ecooutreachvsm.com.

Author

Advertisement
Previous articlePlaces and Faces
Next articleAg Station Drive Thru, No Bugs!