Remember that carnival horse game where rows of toy horses sat in a tiered shelf and each player moved his or her horse by either aiming a water gun at a small hole or by rolling balls into a Skee-Ball type board? Your horse would make small leaps forward the truer your aim. The progress was painstaking, yet everyone was in the same boat.

Now imagine just as you were reaching the finish line, someone walked up to that shelf and grabbed their horse and simply moved it to the end. Stinks of being unfair, un-sportsman-like conduct, right?

Elements of this inequity surfaced during the recent California legislative session over two bills that were aiming to generate hundreds of millions of dollars to go toward journalism: AB 886 (the California Journalism Preservation Act) and SB 1327. As the session neared its close at the end of August, a side deal was made and, as CalMatters summarized, “State lawmakers give up on bills to force tech companies to pay media outlets for using news. Instead, they agree with Google on a program to help local newsrooms and to explore artificial intelligence.”

Advertisement

Here’s a breakdown of the proposed laws, per a fact sheet from Free Press Action:

What’s in AB 886?

The CJPA was first introduced in spring 2023 by Assemblymember Buffy Wicks and is partially modeled off the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act, pending federal legislation currently before Congress. The core idea is that platforms like Google and Meta should compensate news publishers for sharing and accessing their content.

This idea has international roots: In Australia, Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp. joined two of its largest competitors in 2021 to push for the passage of a law that forced platforms to negotiate with news outlets if they wanted to share links to their stories. Canada followed suit with similar legislation in 2023.

The CJPA has undergone amendments since it was first introduced, and a revised version was released earlier this summer.

What’s in SB 1327?

SB 1327 was introduced in spring 2024 by Sen. Steve Glazer, in part to address concerns raised by community publishers, digital rights groups, and ethnic media outlets in 2023. After an initial push for passage in the Senate fell short, it was unexpectedly passed with 2/3 support in late June. (SB 1327 requires a higher vote threshold than the CJPA because it creates a new tax.)

How would the legislation generate revenue to support local journalism?

  • The legislation would impose a “data extraction mitigation fee” — a 7.25% tax on digital advertising revenues originating in California — on major tech platforms. The first $2.5 billion in California revenue that platforms earn from digital advertising is exempt from being taxed.
  • This is estimated to generate roughly $500 million annually for local news.

In contrast, the last-minute deal with Google is a “first-in-the-nation partnership with the state, news publishers, major tech companies and philanthropy,” as announced by Assm. Wicks, and “will provide nearly $250 million in public and private funding over the next five years, with the majority of funding going to newsrooms.”

FIRST IN THE NATION: Assemblymember Buffy Wicks played a key role in negotiating a deal between media outlets and tech companies, which is being touted as a first-in-the-nation partnership. She speaks during a committee hearing in the Capitol Annex Swing Space in Sacramento on Aug. 15, 2024. Photo by Fred Greaves/CalMatters

According to CalMatters, “Instead of Google and Meta being forced to negotiate usage fees with news outlets directly, Google would deposit $55 million over five years into a new fund administered by UC Berkeley to be distributed to local newsrooms — and the state would provide $70 million over five years.” (This statement speaks to AB 886 and not SB 1327, which, as mentioned, was estimated to generate $500 million annually.)

Come again? The effort to get Big Tech to pay up for an issue it has largely caused — the news industry struggling in the face of a tech monopoly — has led to the state investing more funds than the industry itself? (A federal judge ruled in early August that Google “acted illegally to maintain a monopoly in online search,” according to the New York Times, which was “a landmark decision that strikes at the power of tech giants in the modern internet era and that may fundamentally alter the way they do business.”)

To be fair, according to the California deal, Google will also continue with its $10 million each year for existing grants to newsrooms, and will add $12.5 million each year to an artificial intelligence accelerator program. Yet these monies miss the point — one’s already in place and it’s debatable whether publications want to “accelerate” artificial intelligence.

While I applaud Wicks and Glazer for shining a light on journalism and understand that politics is a delicate business, I tend to agree with Senate Democratic leader Mike McGuire who said in a statement that the deal “lacks sufficient funding for newspapers and local media, and doesn’t fully address the inequities facing the industry.”

Some say the news industry is in no position to say no to any help. And perhaps any gain in this horse race is helpful. But it’s not fair and it lacks honor to keep capitulating to the bully who we know is cheating.

Author

Advertisement
Previous articleCherished Moments
Next articleMoonshine Ink Vintage 22 Nip 9

1 COMMENT

  1. I don’t understand why social media sites using copyrighted work for free to generate income constitutes “fair use”. The business model of Google, Facebook, et al depends on using copyrighted content to generate ad revenue. No content, no revenue. Congress needs to update the copyright act for the 21st century. In the meantime maybe the courts can take another look. This might be a situation in which the conservatives on the SCOTUS might actually do the right thing, as I suspect they might be more sympathetic to traditional media–ie newspapers and magazines–then to social media.