“And gosh… Moonshine Ink… why ever would you publish this article?” This question was posed after we shared an opinion piece in the May print edition. The My Shot (what we call the opinion pieces we publish), Intimidation or Inclusion, Which Do You Choose? sparked lively, and at times, contentious conversation among a small group of social media users. Commenters to the post expressed frustration about the author’s experience, disagreeing with her opinion and the manner at which she arrived at it. Some responses questioned Moonshine Ink’s decision to publish the piece at all. The Moonshine team kept an ear (or an eye, as the discourse was strictly online) to the discussion and realized the importance of revisiting the role of opinion pieces in media.
Diverse voices contribute to community discourse. Opinions promote the exchange of ideas, which is the foundation of a healthy, democratic society. Moonshine Ink’s opinion section is designed to provide a platform for individual perspectives and interpretations on various issues, ranging from local politics to environmental concerns, from public transportation to encounters with businesses. The commentary is subjective, and a result of the writer’s experiences, values, and beliefs, reflecting unique perspectives. My Shots give voice to someone who might not otherwise have the chance to share their experience with a wide audience.
Unlike news articles that present objective facts without bias, opinion pieces are, by their nature, biased. Though it’s important to note that opinion pieces are best when they are based on facts, with writers using them to support their argument. And it’s more important than ever to differentiate between a news story and opinion piece, especially in today’s contentious political climate and when biased news stations present their opinion as fact.
Newspapers, Moonshine included, must exercise discretion when publishing opinion pieces. Is it fair? Factual? Well-written? We also balance this process with honoring individual voices. The process is subjective, and we may not always get it right. We encourage readers to call us out, but please do so with respect and clarity, remembering that the author’s views are not representative of Moonshine Ink (unless it is authored by the editorial board).
Publishing opinion pieces that highlight an author’s personal experience with local businesses (as was the case in this situation) is not new nor defamatory. For example, the May issue published two My Shots that described the authors’ experiences with local corporations: Olja Mihic’s How a Resort with the Logo “Smile, You Are at Homewood!” Made Me Cry and Stephan Haase’s Palisades’ Parking Reservations Has Room for Improvement. And this month, the discourse about the Palisades Tahoe parking program continues in Sara Van Siclen’s My Shot, Taming Tahoe’s Traffic: The Impact of New Parking Programs.
The ultimate aim of publishing opinion pieces is not to create division, but to inspire dialogue about worthy topics and meaningful ideas. It sure seems that discord is the MO of social media these days. We’d love to hear your opinions as to why.





