Superior Court Rules Piers are Property

    0

    PLACER COUNTY

    After five and a half years of litigation and a five-day bench trial, the Placer County Superior Court has issued a comprehensive ruling resolving what became one of the most closely watched “pier war” disputes in the Tahoe Basin. The case addressed fundamental and largely unsettled questions about who owns a pier that extends more than 300 feet from private uplands into Lake Tahoe — over state-owned submerged lands regulated by the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (TRPA), the California State Lands Commission (SLC), and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

    The ruling has broad implications for lakefront property owners throughout the Tahoe region:

    • Piers are real property. The court found that a pier permanently affixed to a lakebed by pilings is a fixture — and therefore part of the adjacent upland owner’s real property — applying California fixture doctrine in a context that has rarely been litigated at Lake Tahoe. 
    • Use rights are not ownership rights. The court drew a clear line between the right to use a pier under an access easement and the right to own it — rejecting the argument that shared maintenance costs, “multiple-use” permit designations by TRPA, or joint listing on an SLC lease creates or implies joint ownership. This distinction matters because the overwhelming majority of Lake Tahoe’s approximately 700 existing piers are governed by similar shared-use arrangements.
    • Regulatory permits do not determine private ownership. The court confirmed that neither TRPA, the SLC, nor the Army Corps takes any position on private pier ownership — and that “joint-use” or “multiple-use” language in agency permits reflects regulatory classifications, not ownership determinations. This is significant because property owners and their counsel have frequently pointed to agency designations as evidence of ownership interests.
    • No oral agreement can override California’s title presumption. Despite evidence that the original owners may have discussed joint ownership over 45 years ago, the court held that verbal statements claiming ownership of real property are not conclusive.

    ~ Womble Bond Dickinson LLP press release